Is it a repair or an improvement on a rental property?
A repair keeps the property working the way it already did and is deducted in the year; an improvement makes it better, restores a major part or adapts it to a new use, and is depreciated over years. Small landlords can often deduct more than they expect, through the $2,500 de minimis election and the small taxpayer safe harbor for buildings with an unadjusted basis of $1 million or less.
The test: better, restored or adapted
Under the IRS tangible property rules, money spent on a building is an improvement if it does one of three things. It makes the property better, such as adding a bathroom or fixing a defect that existed when you bought it. It restores the property, such as replacing a major component or a substantial structural part. Or it adapts the property to a new use, such as turning a garage into a unit. Work that keeps the property in its ordinary working condition is a repair.
The test runs on the building structure and on each building system separately: plumbing, electrical, HVAC, elevators, escalators, fire protection, gas distribution and security. A new furnace is measured against the HVAC system, not against the whole building, which is why replacing one is an improvement even though it is a small part of what the building cost.
| Usually a repair | Usually an improvement |
|---|---|
| Fixing a leaking pipe | Replumbing the building |
| Replacing a few broken shingles | A new roof |
| Repainting a unit between tenants | Painting as part of a remodel |
| Replacing the igniter on the furnace | A new furnace or central air |
| Replacing a cracked window pane | New storm windows throughout |
Three safe harbors that favor small landlords
De minimis, $2,500 per invoice or item. Attach the de minimis election statement to your return and you can deduct items that cost $2,500 or less per invoice or per item instead of depreciating them. A $1,100 refrigerator or a $900 stove for a unit qualifies. You make the election each year, on a return filed on time, extensions included, and it covers every qualifying item that year.
Routine maintenance. Recurring work you reasonably expect to do more than once in the building's first 10 years in service, to keep it in its ordinary working condition, can be deducted even where it would otherwise count as a restoration. Servicing the boiler and replacing worn parts with comparable ones fit here. It never covers a betterment.
Small taxpayer safe harbor. If your average annual gross receipts are $10 million or less and a building's unadjusted basis is $1 million or less, you can deduct everything you spent on that building in the year, repairs, maintenance and improvements together, as long as the total is no more than the lesser of $10,000 or 2% of the building's unadjusted basis. You elect it building by building, each year, with a statement on your return. If the total goes over the limit, the safe harbor covers none of it.
A worked example with real numbers
- Unadjusted basis of the building: $360,000 minus $60,000 of land = $300,000
- 2% of $300,000 = $6,000, lower than $10,000, so the limit for this building is $6,000
- Year one: a $1,800 water heater + $2,900 to repaint two units at turnover + $900 of plumbing repairs = $5,600
- $5,600 is under $6,000: elect the small taxpayer safe harbor and deduct all of it, the water heater included
- Year two: the same work plus a $9,000 roof = $14,600, over $6,000, so the safe harbor covers none of it
- Year two, then: the repainting and plumbing are still repairs, $3,800 deducted as usual
- The roof is an improvement: $9,000 over 27.5 years is about $327 a full year
The water heater is the hard case in year two. The IRS lists a water heater among examples of improvements, so outside the small taxpayer safe harbor ask your preparer whether your de minimis election reaches it before you deduct it.
Keep the paper that shows which one it was
- The invoice, with the work described in words. Replaced 3 broken shingles reads very differently from new roof.
- Before and after photos of anything over a few hundred dollars.
- For an improvement, the month it went into service and its full cost, because you need both for depreciation every year and again when you sell.
- A copy of each year's election statements.
Your next step
List everything you spent on each building this year with the amount, total it per building, and compare the total with 2% of that building's unadjusted basis. If you are under the limit, ask your preparer to attach the small taxpayer safe harbor election for that building.
Questions landlords ask
Is painting a rental unit a repair or an improvement?
Usually a repair. Repainting between tenants keeps the unit in its usual condition, while painting done as part of a remodel is part of that improvement.
Is a new roof on a rental a repair?
No. A new roof replaces a major component and is an improvement, depreciated over 27.5 years, unless the small taxpayer safe harbor covers that year's total for the building.
What is the de minimis safe harbor limit for a small landlord?
$2,500 per invoice or per item. You elect it each year with a statement on a return filed on time, and it applies to every qualifying item that year.
Can I use the small taxpayer safe harbor on a building that cost more than $1 million?
No. The building's unadjusted basis must be $1 million or less, and your average annual gross receipts $10 million or less.
Where Tierna fits
In Tierna a repair goes in as an expense under Repairs, for the property and the unit it was for, and lands on line 14 of the Schedule E report. Invoices and before and after photos can be attached to the property, the unit or the tenant they concern, so the paper that shows which side of the line a job was on stays with the building.
It is a quiet place to keep this for landlords with a few units, in English or Spanish, so the list in your next step is already written when tax time comes.